2010 Lindsey Carden
2009 Kirsten Fletter
2nd Runner-Up, Miss Indiana State Fair
2008 Kate Taylor
2007 Katie Fox
2006 Rachel Berry
2005 Jessica Pontius
2004 Michelle Shiriaev-Love
3rd Runner-Up, Miss Indiana State Fair
2003 Meghan Marhenke
2002 Tanya Hadley-Hall
1st Runner-up, Miss Indiana State Fair
2001 Abigail Puff-Zakhi
Top 10, Miss Indiana State Fair
2000 Ashley Primeau
4th Runner-Up, Miss Indiana State Fair
1999 Desiree McFarren-Fritcha
Top 16, Miss Indiana State Fair
1998 Julie Fuhrmann
1997 Ericka Helfrich-Howell
Sweet 16, Miss Indiana State Fair
1996 Melissa Albano-Barth
1995 Holly Gray
1994 Gianna Scappucci
Indiana State Fair Queen
1993 Nicole Helfrich-McVicker
Indiana State Fair Queen
1992 Amy Hassig-Smith
1991 Rachael Helfich-Roberts
Top 10, Miss Indiana State Fair
1990 Kelly Dwyer-Werth
Indiana State Fair Queen
*We are trying very hard to perserve the history of the Miss Allen County Queen Scholarship Pageant. If you know of any corrections or additions to the information provided, please contact missallencounty@gmail.com.